Renovation-Headquarters.com

Home
Main Index

 

Hardwood Flooring
Versus
Vinyl Sheet Flooring
Comparison

The following chart provides a comparison between hardwood and vinyl sheet flooring materials.

Consideration Hardwood Vinyl Sheet

Appearance

  • Elegant - Class
  • No two floors are ever identical due to variance in wood grains
  • Numerous installation patterns and designs can be created

Additional information on hardwood flooring patterns and designs

  • Numerous board widths
  • Domestic & exotic woods
  • Array of stain colors, gloss factors, edge details
  • Ornamental insets available
  • Large variety of patterns and colors including hardwood, tile and mosaics

Typical Warranties

  • Prefinished:

Structural Integrity - Lifetime

Finish - 3 to 25 years

  • Unfinished:

Varies dramatically

  • Better quality lifetime on manufacturer's defects and wear through
  • Rips, tears, gouges and stains, 5 to 20 years

Life Expectancy

  • Pending no damage from external sources, the hardwood itself will last for hundred's of years.
  • 10 to 20 years

Child Friendly

  • Can be scratched
  • Liquid spills can damage surface and cause boards to warp and rot
  • Very child friendly
  • Liquid spills can damage surface and cause boards rot

Pet Friendly

  • Can be scratched
  • Very pet friendly

Care & Maintenance

  • Vacuum & mop using non-wax cleaners
  • Recoat with polyurethane as needed
  • Can be refinished - refinishing required every 15 to 25 years
  • Sweep & mop using manufacturer's recommended cleaners

Installation

  • Nails, staples or glue

3/4" or 5/8" thick: Nail to wood

5/16" thick: Staple or glue to wood, concrete or existing floor with the exception of carpet

  • Adhesive

Felt: Full-spread or perimeter adhesive

Fiberglass: Loose - lay, modified loose - lay or full-spread

Both products can be installed over concrete, hardwood, plywood, or existing floor (except carpet)

Grade Levels

  • Below grade only in very dry regions
  • On grade
  • Above grade
  • Below grade
  • On grade
  • Above grade

Room Installation

  • All rooms with following exceptions:
  • Full & half bathrooms - not recommended - hardwood is very sensitive to humidity fluctuations and water
  • Below grade basements - not recommended - hardwood may buckle or warp with fluctuations in moisture level

Note: As hardwood scratches consideration should be given to installations in foyers as dirt brought into the home can scratch the surface.

  • All rooms no exceptions.

Budgeting

  • Material cost $3/sq. ft. to $30/sq. ft. - very dependent on quality and dimensions of hardwood boards, finish and species.
  • Installation cost (contractor):

Prefinished - $2/sq. ft. to $6/sq. ft.

Unfinished hardwood, finished on site - $6/sq. ft. to $10/sq. ft.

Note: Sq. ft. installation prices do not include the material or installation costs of underlayment, or repairs to sub-floors.

Note: Installing hardwood flooring on steps is not included in the pricing.

Additional information on budgeting for hardwood flooring

  • Material cost $0.50/sq. ft. to $5/sq. ft. - dependent on quality of material and finish
  • Installation cost (contractor):

$0.75/sq. ft. to $4/sq. ft.

DIY Complexity - Scale 1 to 5 with 1 being the easiest.

  • 3/4" or 5/8" thick, with nails - 4
  • 5/16" thick, with glue or staples - 3
  • Felt: Full-spread or perimeter adhesive - 4
  • Fiberglass: Full-spread - 4
  • Fiberglass: Loose-lay or modified loose-lay - 3

Additional information on flooring materials

Other Flooring Comparison Charts

Hardwood /

Engineered Hardwood

Laminate

Vinyl Sheet

Vinyl Sheet /

Hardwood

Linoleum

Vinyl Tile

Laminate /

Engineered Hardwood

Hardwood